SubscribeSign in
America Still Needs Counterinsurgency
The “Forever Wars” Are Ending, But the Fight Against Terrorists and Guerrillas Will Go On
Max Boot

June 2, 2021
A U.S. military vehicle near Camp Gorgak in Helmand province, Afghanistan, July 2011
Shamil Zhumatov / Reuters
In 2006, when the U.S. war in Iraq was at its low point, the American military rediscovered counterinsurgency (COIN). This doctrine, developed in the 1950s by military innovators such as the British field marshal Gerald Templer in Malaya and the U.S. operative Edward Lansdale in the Philippines, holds that a military can’t defeat an insurgency by simply killing insurgents. In fact, by killing indiscriminately, one may actually create more enemies than one eliminates. The way to prevail, according to COIN doctrine, is to provide ordinary people with security and basic services. Doing so helps counterinsurgents earn people’s trust, making it more likely that they will provide the vital intelligence necessary to kill or capture hardcore insurgents without harming innocent civilians.
Two generals—David Petraeus of the U.S. Army and James Mattis of the U.S. Marine Corps—collaborated on a seminal field manual, published in December 2006, that popularized COIN thinking. In the years that followed, Petraeus applied COIN doctrine as commander of U.S. forces in Iraq. The “surge” he oversaw wound up reducing violence there by more than 90 percent.  Although U.S. troops could not resolve underlying ethnosectarian tensions or turn Iraq into a model
Finish reading this article for free.
Enter your email and we'll send a paywall-free link directly to your inbox.
In addition to your unlocked article, you will receive our flagship weekly newsletter Foreign Affairs This Week, as well as occasional updates and offers from Foreign Affairs. You can unsubscribe at any time. For more information, visit our user agreement and privacy policy.
Get unlimited access to all Foreign Affairs. Subscribe now.
Are you already a subscriber? Sign in.
MAX BOOT is Jeane J. Kirkpatrick Senior Fellow for National Security Studies at the Council on Foreign Relations and the author of The Road Not Taken: Edward Lansdale and the American Tragedy in Vietnam.
More:Afghanistan Middle East Security War & Military Strategy Terrorism & CounterterrorismU.S. Foreign Policy
Recommended Articles
How the Good War Went Bad
America’s Slow-Motion Failure in Afghanistan
Carter Malkasian
A Few Good Men
Trump, the Generals, and the Corrosion of Civil-Military Relations
Max Boot
Save up to 55%
on Foreign Affairs magazine!
Weekly Newsletter
Get in-depth analysis delivered right to your inbox
From the
publishers of
Foreign Affairs
The Most:
Malaysia Faces Crises on All Levels
by Joshua Kurlantzick
Five Movies Worth Watching About Conflict at Sea
by James M. Lindsay
A Conversation with Catharine A. MacKinnon: Prostitution as Sex Work or Sexual Exploitation?
by Catherine Powell
Published by the Council on Foreign Relations
Privacy Policy Terms of Use
©2021 Council on Foreign Relations, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
This site uses cookies to improve your user experience. Click here to learn more.
Subscribe for unrestricted access.
Explore Current Issue Archive Books & Reviews Anthologies Newsletters Search Subscribe