SubscribeSign in
The Clash of Systems?
Washington Should Avoid Ideological Competition With Beijing
Thomas Pepinsky and Jessica Chen Weiss
June 11, 2021
Chinese schoolchildren play next to a portrait of Soviet leader Joseph Stalin at the Democracy Elementary and Middle School in Sitong, Henan province, December 2013
Carlos Barria / Reuters
In Europe this week, on his first overseas trip since taking office, U.S. President Joe Biden has framed the current moment in world politics as an existential choice between democracy and autocracy, a fundamental decision that, as he put it in a speech in Pittsburgh on March 31, is “what competition between America and China and the rest of the world is all about.” China’s economic success and political durability have indeed demonstrated that development does not require democratization. And as China grows more influential, it may “ultimately present a stronger ideological challenge than the Soviet Union did,” as Kurt Campbell and Jake Sullivan noted in these pages in 2019.
The Biden administration is correct to emphasize the challenges facing democracy around the world, but the more immediate threat to the United States and other democracies lies within, not without. At present, the dangers of conceiving of U.S.-Chinese competition as a global contest between democratic and autocratic systems outweigh the benefits. Domestically, invoking competition with China may seem like an attractive way to build bipartisan support for long-overdue investments at home. But such appeals are unlikely to sway Republican members of Congress and may validate their efforts
Finish reading this article for free.
Enter your email and we'll send a paywall-free link directly to your inbox.
In addition to your unlocked article, you will receive our flagship weekly newsletter Foreign Affairs This Week, as well as occasional updates and offers from Foreign Affairs. You can unsubscribe at any time. For more information, visit our user agreement and privacy policy.
Get unlimited access to all Foreign Affairs. Subscribe now.
Are you already a subscriber? Sign in.
THOMAS PEPINSKY is Walter F. LaFeber Professor of Government at Cornell University and a Nonresident Senior Fellow at the Brookings Institution.
JESSICA CHEN WEISS is Associate Professor of Government at Cornell University and the author of Powerful Patriots: Nationalist Protest in China’s Foreign Relations.
More:United States China World EconomicsU.S. Foreign Policy
Recommended Articles
America Is Not Ready for a War With China
How to Get the Pentagon to Focus on the Real Threats
Michael Beckley
The World Hasn’t Given Up on America
Trump Damaged the United States’ Global Reputation—but Not Permanently
Richard Wike
Save up to 55%
on Foreign Affairs magazine!
Weekly Newsletter
Get in-depth analysis delivered right to your inbox
From the
publishers of
Foreign Affairs
The Most:
Malaysia Faces Crises on All Levels
by Joshua Kurlantzick
Five Movies Worth Watching About Conflict at Sea
by James M. Lindsay
A Conversation with Catharine A. MacKinnon: Prostitution as Sex Work or Sexual Exploitation?
by Catherine Powell
Published by the Council on Foreign Relations
Privacy Policy Terms of Use
©2021 Council on Foreign Relations, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
This site uses cookies to improve your user experience. Click here to learn more.
Subscribe for unrestricted access.
Explore Current Issue Archive Books & Reviews Anthologies Newsletters Search Subscribe