We use cookies, tracking technologies, and third-party analytics tools to better understand who is using the website and improve your experience. By using our website you are agreeing to this. Read our privacy policy to find out what cookies are used for and how to change your settings.
November 15, 2019 11:32AM EST
Facial Recognition Deal in Kyrgyzstan Poses Risks to Rights
Use of Same Tech in Xinjiang Should Serve as Warning
Laura Mills
Researcher, Rights of Older People
Maya Wang
China Senior Researcher
An airplane trace is seen behind a Kyrgyzstan national flag fluttering in a central square in Bishkek March 11, 2013. © 2013 Reuters
On October 31, Kyrgyzstan President Sooronbay Jeenbekov inaugurated a new police command center in the capital city of Bishkek. But this local event had an international human rights dimension: the center will manage a network of cameras equipped with facial recognition technology and installed throughout the city. It is also provided by and paid for, at least in part, by a Chinese state company.
In March, Kyrgyzstan’s government signed an agreement with China National Electronic Import and Export Corporation (CEIEC) to install technology to improve “public and road safety.” But there was little transparency around the deal and how facial images of Kyrgyz people and other personal data would be collected, stored, and transferred. It is also unclear whether there are legal safeguards that restrict CEIEC from accessing such data. Human Rights Watch wrote to CEIEC for more information but received no reply.
The use of facial recognition technology in public spaces can allow governments to track and monitor people’s habits and movements, creating potential chilling effects on freedoms of expression and assembly. It can also be used to single out individuals in discriminatory ways, including for their ethnicity or religion. In Kyrgyzstan, the rollout of facial recognition technology was approved without public consultation or necessary transparency, making it unclear how or if the government plans to mitigate the technology’s potential impact on privacy.
The situation in the Chinese region of Xinjiang should serve as a warning to Kyrgyz citizens. When deployed with few actionable privacy rights or protections, this technology can facilitate gross human rights violations. In Xinjiang, the Chinese government uses various technologies including facial recognition, surveillance cameras, and big data programs to monitor and track ethnic Uyghur and other citizens. Anyone flagged as “problematic” based on vague criteria may be sent to “political education camps” and subjected to political indoctrination.
Kyrgyz laws establish some privacy protections. The Kyrgyz constitution enshrines the right to privacy, the Law on Biometric Registration requires that individuals consent to data collection, and the Law on Personal Information bans the collection of personal data without consent.
But these laws also create broad exemptions for national security or law enforcement purposes, and there is no law regulating facial recognition technology specifically. The opaque terms of the CEIEC deal create the risk that the Kyrgyz government could use increased security as a blanket justification for mass surveillance of its citizens.
Under international human rights law, Kyrgyzstan has obligations to ensure that government collection, retention, and use of biometrics is well-regulated, narrow in scope, and necessary and proportionate to meeting a legitimate security goal. The Kyrgyz government should pause the rollout of facial recognition technology, disclose the details of this deal, and provide privacy protections that meet international standards.
Your tax deductible gift can help stop human rights violations and save lives around the world.
Region / Country
China and Tibet
Europe/Central Asia
China's Global Influence
Technology and Rights
October 30, 2019 Dispatches
Countries Blast China at UN Over Xinjiang Abuses
May 28, 2019 Report
July 28, 2021 Report
The Impact of the Covid-19 Pandemic on People Living in Poverty in Lagos, Nigeria
July 22, 2021 Report
Why Car Companies Should Address the Human Rights Impact of Aluminum Production
May 17, 2021 News Release
July 29, 2021 Report
July 28, 2021 Commentary
July 27, 2021 News Release
April 27, 2021 Report
Protecting Rights, Saving Lives
Human Rights Watch defends the rights of people in 90 countries worldwide, spotlighting abuses and bringing perpetrators to justice
Get Updates On Rights Issues From Around The Globe
Connect With Us
Contact Us
Privacy Policy
Blackbaud Security Incident
© 2021 Human Rights Watch
Human Rights Watch | 350 Fifth Avenue, 34th Floor | New York, NY 10118-3299 USA | t
Human Rights Watch is a 501(C)(3) nonprofit registered in the US under EIN: 13-2875808
Reports Video & Photos Impact Take Action Iranian Society under Crackdown 3 new posts Ethiopia 2 new posts Japan 4 new posts Myanmar (Burma) 7 new posts Coronavirus 13 new posts Philippines’ ‘War on Drugs’ Reports Video & Photos Impact Take Action العربية 简中 繁中 English Français Deutsch 日本語 Русский Português Español More
English 简体中文 繁體中文 Русский