Evaluating Iran's Twitter Revolution
JUNE 18, 2010
At the height of mass post-election protests that took place a year ago this month in Iran, known as the "Green Revolution," Western media outlets were filled with a flurry of reports of protesters using Twitter, e-mail, blogs, and text messages to coordinate rallies, share information, and locate compatriots. Journalists were agape at the sudden influx of information coming out of the country, unusual in light of the Iranian authorities' media blackout. "The immediacy of the reports was gripping," reported the Washington Times. "Well-developed Twitter lists showed a constant stream of situation updates and links to photos and videos, all of which painted a portrait of the developing turmoil. Digital photos and videos proliferated and were picked up and reported in countless external sources safe from the regime's Net crackdown." Journalists even gave the unrest in Tehran a second moniker: the "Twitter Revolution."
But was there really a "Twitter Revolution?" Radio Free Europe's Golnaz Esfandiari recently described the idea in Foreign Policy as "an irresistible meme during the post-election protests, a story that wrote itself." Esfandiari explained that opposition activists primarily utilized text messages, email, and blog posts to organize protests, while "good old-fashioned word of mouth" was most influential medium for coordinating opposition. Social media tools like Facebook and Twitter were not ideal for rapid communication among protestors, and utilized more by observers in other countries. "Western journalists who couldn't reach -- or didn't bother reaching? -- people on the ground in Iran simply scrolled through the English-language tweets posted with tag #iranelection," quipped Esfandiari. "Through it all, no one seemed to wonder why people trying to coordinate protests in Iran would be writing in any language other than Farsi."
The concept of a "Twitter Revolution," as challenged by Esfandiari and others, is rooted in the idea that Twitter was the lifeblood of the Green revolution. Taking this definition, Esfandiari and other critics are right: Twitter was no secret weapon that magically made the Islamic Republic disappear. "Twitter cannot stop a bullet," mused Charles Krauthammer on the Green Revolution's anniversary. "There was a lot of romantic outpouring here thinking that Facebook is going to stop the Revolutionary Guards. It doesn't. Thuggery, a determined regime that is oppressive, that will shoot, almost always wins." Social media tools like Facebook and Twitter, now our bread and butter, were more influential in mobilizing Diaspora Iranians and international observers in solidarity rather than coordinating street protests inside Iran.
But while Twitter failed as an organizational tool, the Green movement remains the first major world event broadcast worldwide almost entirely via social media. Given the extent of the Iranian regime of repression, the amount of information publicized real-time through social networks allowed the international community an unprecedented peek into the turmoil afflicting Iran. For the Greens, the international reaction to the post-election violence gave the movement critical international visibility. While crowd sourcing is now a familiar concept to even the marginally tech-savvy, Twitter's use on a massive scale was rarely contemplated nor executed prior to the Iranian election. The Green revolution was a Twitter revolution; while social media fell short organizationally, it brought the violence in the streets of Tehran to the forefront of the geopolitical conversation.
The unprecedented use of Twitter also situated the micro-blogging service at the center of a global social transformation. The Green Revolution was far from social media's political coming-out party; Barack Obama's media-centric 2008 presidential campaign was an early testing ground for new media as a means for political communication and organization, and the practices pioneered there quickly spread to other political movements around the globe. But it was the critical role of Twitter as a lightning rod for international attention that established it as a tool for political communication rather than outright organization. Iran's post-election unrest was the micro-blogging service's baptism by fire as a means to observe, report, and record, real-time, the unfolding of a crisis.
The Green Revolution in Iran was muzzled, sadly, its political organs now defunct and its development totally stifled although the movement continues to put pressure on the Iranian regime a year after its initial protests. The Twitter Revolution, however, is far from over.
JARED KELLER is a journalist based in New York. He has written for Bloomberg Businessweek, Pacific Standard, and Al Jazeera America, and is a former associate editor for The Atlantic.
Subscribe for less than $1 per week
Make your inbox more interesting.
Each weekday evening, get an overview of the day’s biggest news, along with fascinating ideas, images, and people. See more newsletters
Email Address
Ideas that matter. Since 1857.
Subscribe and support 162 years of independent journalism. For less than $1 a week.
Don’t miss what matters.
Gain clarity on the biggest stories of the day with our flagship newsletter, The Atlantic Daily.
Privacy Policy
SKIP TO CONTENTThe AtlanticPopularLatestPoliticsIdeasPhotoScienceCulturePodcastsHealthEducationPlanetTechnologyFamilyProjectsBusinessGlobalEventsBooksFictionNewslettersPlay Crosswordthe latest issue of the atlanticLatest IssuePast IssuesGive a GiftDear TherapistCrossword PuzzleManage SubscriptionPopularLatestSign InSubscribe
Read More: You’re Gonna Miss Zoom When It’s GoneYou’re Gonna Miss Zoom When It’s GoneOLGA KHAZANRead More: The Alt-Right Has Lost Control of <em>Redpill</em>The Alt-Right Has Lost Control of RedpillKAITLYN TIFFANYRead More: An Unexpected Boon to America’s Vaccine TownsAn Unexpected Boon to America’s Vaccine TownsDANIEL BLOCK
glimpseBen ParrVictor HerreroFacebookGoogleelections
1Are Outdoor Mask Mandates Still Necessary?DEREK THOMPSONIllustration of a person who has a tree for a face wearing a mask.2Compliance Will Not Save MeIBRAM X. KENDIAn illustration of two arms3No, You’re Crying About a Helicopter on MarsMARINA KORENThe Ingenuity helicopter on the surface of Mars4The Two Memos With Enormous Constitutional ConsequencesKIMBERLY WEHLEA broken judge's gavel and the White House5They Get Taxed, but Not VaxxedYASMEEN SERHANA syringe surrounded by red and blue location pins6The Interior Lives of HoardersALYSE BURNSIDEMan on ladder next to stacks of books7Dear Therapist: My Girlfriend Had an Affair With My Co-workerLORI GOTTLIEBAn illustration of two men in the bathroom looking in the mirror. The reflected image shows the man on the right punching the man on the left.8How America Ruined SoccerTOM MCTAGUEA slingshot with a soccer ball9Gen-X Women Are Caught in a Generational Tug-of-WarADA CALHOUNA toddler feeding an elderly woman from a fork.10Private Schools Have Become Truly ObsceneCAITLIN FLANAGANillustration: a solid gold school desk on a pink background
Our HistoryStaffCareersHelp CenterContact UsAtlantic Brand PartnersPressThe ExperimentSocial Distance™FloodlinesThe Ticket: Politics from The AtlanticCrazy/GeniusPurchaseGive a GiftManage SubscriptionDownload iOS AppNewslettersfacebookinstagramyoutubetwitterlinkedinflipboardrssOur HistoryStaffCareersHelp CenterContact UsAtlantic Brand PartnersPressThe ExperimentSocial Distance™FloodlinesThe Ticket: Politics from The AtlanticCrazy/GeniusPurchaseGive a GiftManage SubscriptionDownload iOS AppNewslettersfacebookinstagramyoutubetwitterlinkedinflipboardrss
Privacy PolicyDo Not Sell My Personal InformationAdvertising GuidelinesTerms ConditionsResponsible DisclosureSite Map