SUBSCRIBESIGN IN
OPINION WONDER LAND
Democrats Are Killing the American Dream
Joe Biden’s American Families Plan replaces individual striving with middle class entitlements.
By
May 5, 2021 5:48 pm ET
SHARE
TEXT
1,706
President Biden signs an executive order in the Oval Office, Feb. 2.
PHOTO: EVAN VUCCI/ASSOCIATED PRESS
President Biden’s American Families Act makes one political reality officially clear: The Democratic Party has given up on the American dream.
The Biden proposals—coming as they do with the Democratic progressives’ rise to power—present the American people with a once-in-a-lifetime decision about what kind of country they want to live in for the next half-century.
This isn’t about the culture wars or standard Keynesian stimulus spending. The Biden plan is about public policies that will redesign American society.
The American Families Plan and other recent Democratic legislation implicitly pose several important questions. Is the traditional American idea of upward mobility still important? If so, how should upward mobility happen—through Washington or individual effort? Indeed, should the habit of individual striving give way to a presumably more important goal of nationalized paternalism?
It is no surprise that a liberalism that embraced the “1619 Project’s” rewriting of the U.S.’s founding history would not stop there and try now, despite its almost invisible congressional majority, to displace the country’s originating idea of individual opportunity with a broad birth-to-death entitlement state.
This transition began in March, when Democrats enacted a federal unemployment-insurance bonus of $300. That bonus, pushing benefits past market wage rates, indisputably is causing many to shun previously held jobs, which surely will do long-term damage to the notion of working to get ahead.
Why bother? Instead, hold out for all this new state-subsidized compensation that reduces the incentive or need to work—the same skip-work choice public-school teachers across the country have made the past year.
Mr. Biden’s American Families Plan proposes four significant new federal entitlements: two years of free, universal prekindergarten; virtually free child care for all; a paid family and medical leave program; and two years of community college.
Nowhere will you find a Democrat calling these proposals what they are—entitlements like Medicaid, Medicare and Social Security. Rejecting that criticism at his news conference Wednesday, Mr. Biden said all his spending will “create” jobs and growth.
His progressive colleagues don’t justify spending as optimism about the American system or its private economy. For years, the word favored by progressive analysts to describe the U.S. economy has been “stagnation.”
READ MORE WONDER LAND
Joe Biden’s European Vacation June 16, 2021
Joe Biden Bungles His Crisis June 9, 2021
Banning Critical Race Theory June 2, 2021
The Pelosi January 6 Commission Fiasco May 26, 2021
Law and Order: It’s Back May 19, 2021
Though this argument is disputable, they say private-sector wage growth in the U.S. has been stagnant since the 1970s, isn’t likely to improve and that middle-class survival isn’t possible without replacement income in the form of federal social-welfare programs. Some conservatives agree but purport not to want Mr. Biden’s entitlements.
At his news conference, Mr. Biden made the manifestly false claim (also falsely citing the Heritage Foundation in support) that the Trump administration’s policies produced minimal economic benefit. In fact, before the onset of the pandemic last year, median household income in 2019 grew 6.8%, with higher increases among blacks, Hispanics, Asians and women. Unemployment for these classes hit historic lows. Possibly Mr. Biden was distracted with something else then and never heard about these gains.
Americans need to understand the realities of what Mr. Biden is offering them. Bernie Sanders wanted “Medicare for all,” but that applied only to healthcare. Mr. Biden’s reach goes beyond even Bernie, proposing what will become Medicaid for everything.
Medicaid is minimalist, bare-bones healthcare for the poor. Because of its scale and cost, it is necessarily lowest-common-denominator healthcare. When Joe Biden and the progressive Democratic Party demand “equity” everywhere, they are proposing a lowest-common-denominator society.
The reality of the new Biden entitlement is that costs will be contained, even nominally, only by defaulting over time to Medicaid-quality child care and universal pre-K.
But what if the progressive analysis is correct—that most Americans are ready to accept new middle-class entitlements as a substitute for centuries of individual striving?
Mr. Biden himself made this proposition clear in an interview Monday on the “Today” show when he said that “after 400 years,” black Americans remain “far behind the eight ball in terms of education, health, in terms of opportunity.”
If the American Families Plan passes, we’ll all be behind the same federal dependency eight-ball.
Generations of similar welfare compensation eroded the American dream for many black Americans by disincentivizing upward mobility. Hundreds of thousand still live in public-housing units built for them in the mid-1960s. The unions whose teachers refuse to return to inner-city schools will run child care.
The Biden Democrats not only don’t apologize for this malgovernance, they want to spread it to the nonpoor.
If Republicans let the Biden entitlements become law this year, they will indeed become tax collectors for the permanent welfare state, with payroll-tax increases or a national value-added tax becoming inevitable. The current Biden entitlement pay-fors—higher taxes on corporations and the 1%—are obviously preposterous as long-term support.
And permanently unanswered will be whether American parents ever actually concluded that traditional paths upward are out of reach for them, their children and grandchildren.
Come to think of it, that turns out to be the true big steal in the 2020 election: Joe Biden never asked voters if they wanted to replace the American dream. He’s doing it anyway.
Write henninger@wsj.com.
Play video on original page
Play video on original page
Journal Editorial Report: It's the biggest entitlement expansion since the 1960s. Images: Getty Images Composite: Mark Kelly
Appeared in the May 6, 2021, print edition as 'Killing the American Dream.'
JOIN THE CONVERSATION
Many Companies Want Remote Workers—Except From Colorado
West Risks Blackouts as Hydroelectric Power Dries Up
Funding for Bezos Space Company Fails to Launch in House
Supreme Court Ruling on Affordable Care Act Emboldens Democrats
Capital Gains: A Century-Old Tax Break Gets a Rush of Attention
WSJ News Exclusive | SEC Investigating Former Chair of Auditing Industry Regulator
How Green Was My Tesla—and How Cheap?
Thieves Find Money That Grows on Trees: ‘Avocados Are the Green Gold’
Tech Industry’s Glory Days in Washington Are Over
Supreme Court Leaves Affordable Care Act Intact
About this article
Wonder Land
“Wonder Land” tries to make sense of the world's wonder, which in the newspaper business arrives every day of the week. It's published weekly on Wednesday evenings.
Daniel Henninger
Daniel Henninger is deputy editor of The Wall Street Journal's editorial page. His weekly column, “Wonder Land,” appears in The Wall Street Journal each Thursday.
Mr. Henninger was a finalist for a Pulitzer Prize in editorial writing in 1987 and 1996, and shared in the Journal's Pulitzer Prize in 2002 for the paper's coverage of the attacks on September 11. In 2004, he won the Eric Breindel Journalism Award for his weekly column. He has won the Gerald Loeb Award for commentary, the Scripps Howard Foundation's Walker Stone Award for editorial writing and the American Society of Newspaper Editors' Distinguished Writing Award for editorial writing. He is a weekly panelist on the "Journal Editorial Report" on Fox News.
A native of Cleveland, Mr. Henninger is a graduate of Georgetown University’s School of Foreign Service. Follow him @danhenninger.
SPONSORED OFFERS
TARGET:
20% off sitewide - Target Promo Code 2021
MACY'S:
Macy's coupon - Sign up to get 25% off next order
KOHL'S:
30% off Kohl's coupon for Rewards members
SAKS FIFTH AVENUE:
20% off first order - Saks Fifth Avenue promo code
OLD NAVY:
50% off Father's day apparel at Old Navy
PRETTYLITTLETHING:
Extra 10% off - PrettyLittleThing coupon
UPCOMING EVENTS
June
24
2021
11:00 AM - 5:00 PM EDT
Global Food Forum
June
30
2021
1:00 PM - 1:45 PM EDT
WSJ Pro Cybersecurity Webinar: Aligning IT and Cybersecurity
June
30
2021
7:00 PM - 7:45 PM EDT
WSJ+ Live: Daniel Kahneman and His Co-Authors on the Crisis of ‘Noise’
ADD TO CALENDAR
BACK TO TOP
Edition
WSJ Membership Benefits
Customer Center
Legal Policies
SIGN IN
© 2021 Dow Jones & Company Inc.
All Rights Reserved.
DJIA Futurespoints with a0.96%▼U.S. 10 Yrwith a1.508%▲Europoints with a0.18%▼