Equality bill: Why you can still be fired in US for being gay
Anthony Zurcher
North America reporter
29 August 2019
Taylor Swift has endorsed the Equality Act at the 2019 Video Music Awards
In May the Democratic-controlled House of Representatives passed sweeping new civil rights protections for LGBT Americans. The Republican-controlled Senate has yet to act, however, and supporters of the legislation - including pop star Taylor Swift - are getting frustrated.
The Equality Act, as it's called, expands workplace, education and public accommodation protections that currently prohibit discrimination based on race, gender and disability to include sexual preference and gender identity.
The federal law would nationalise legal safeguards that are currently afforded to varying extent in only 22 states and the District of Columbia. In the remaining states, it is legal for individuals to be refused employment, housing or business services because of their sexual preference or gender identity.
The Human Rights Campaign, which has been a champion of the bill, points to the story of Carter Brown, who was outed as transgender at his workplace. He was harassed by co-workers and subsequently fired. Because he lives in Texas, which does not have protections for sexual identity, he had no legal recourse.
"If the Equality Act had been in place during my employment, it would have been illegal for my employer to engage in harassment and fire me because I was transgender," Brown told a congressional committee. "My family would not have had to shoulder the burden of my loss of income and worry about my emotional health."
While accepting an MTV Video Music Award for her pro-LGBT song on Monday, Swift - who has become an outspoken critic of the president - said the Equality Act "basically just says we all deserve equal rights under the law". She added that the White House had not responded to her Change.org petition with more than half a million signatures calling for passage of the legislation. She paused and pantomimed tapping a watch on her wrist.
The following day, she received a response - from White House senior counsellor Kellyanne Conway.
Taylor Swift takes top prize at MTV VMAs
The mystery photos of a 1957 gay wedding
"I would love to survey the [award show] audience if they know what the Equality Act even is and isn't," she said in a Fox News interview that included an attempt to sing a few lines from Swift's You Need to Calm Down. "But she's welcome to her opinion. I can tell you, there's a lot of poison pills in it."
Ms Conway and other White House officials have not specified the nature of the "poison pills" that prevent them from supporting the Equality Act, but criticism of the legislation from conservatives largely centres around what they view as its infringement on religious liberties.
Mrs Conway sang a Swift song to the press to criticise her political position
Ryan Anderson, a senior research fellow at the conservative Heritage Foundation, writes that proposed laws like the Equality act "threaten the freedom of citizens, individually and in associations, to affirm their religious or moral convictions - convictions such as that marriage is the union of one man and one woman or that maleness and femaleness are objective biological realities to be valued and affirmed, not rejected or altered".
A recent Supreme Court case upheld the rights of a Christian-owned bakery from preparing a wedding cake for a gay marriage. Opponents of the Equality Act are concerned the legislation could override that decision, prevent religious-affiliated schools (like the one that employs Vice-President Mike Pence's wife, Karen) from banning gay teachers and force medical employees to perform procedures they object to on religious grounds.
Pence condemns LGBT criticism of his wife
No single gene associated with being gay
Taylor Swift backs equal pay for US footballers
Other conservatives have focused on the legislation's emphasis on gender self-identification, contending that it blurs the line between the sexes and could undermine civil rights protections for women.
Congressman Doug Collins of Georgia warned that the act could force athletic competitions to allow transgender participants.
"Never before in American history has one political party tried to so dramatically rewrite federal civil rights laws to include an undefined, self-referential, ideologically driven term - 'gender identity' - in the US Code, applicable to literally any entity that receives federal financial assistance, including elementary schools, colleges and health care centres nationwide," he said during a speech on the floor of the House of Representatives.
Other conservatives have taken a more conciliatory attitude towards the legislation, suggesting that the Senate could modify the House language to include religious protections.
The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites.
View original tweet on Twitter
Stanley Carlson-Thies, senior director of the Institutional Religious Freedom Alliance, describes this "Fairness for All" proposal as a more even-handed approach.
"The legal framework of Fairness for All does not require dropping one's religious and moral commitments, but rather provides guidelines and guardrails to enable us to live together well despite, and with, our varied worldviews and beliefs," he writes.
There is still no indication that Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell, who has the final say in the matter, will bring the Equality Act to the floor for a vote or modification. The House's legislation could effectively be left to gather dust, like many other pieces of progressive legislation passed by Democrats in Congress's lower chamber.
The dispute could end up being an issue in the upcoming presidential election, as well, with every Democratic candidate calling for the law's passage.
You may also like:
Why are some places gay-friendly and not others?
Prince William: 'I'd support my child if they were gay'
LGBT groups call for UK gender law reform
"It's on my colleagues in the Senate to be on the right side of history, prove they represent all of their constituents, and provide equal rights and protection to every American," writes Massachusetts Senator Elizabeth Warren in a Change.org post praising Swift's petition. "We will keep fighting until everyone can live proudly, without fear."
In the meantime, both sides are waging a similar fight in the US judicial system.
In the autumn, the US Supreme Court will consider cases on whether existing civil rights law already prohibits employers from firing workers because of their sexual orientation or transgender identity. It was the highest court that nationalised gay marriage rights in 2015, and it has the power to do something similar here.
With the current conservative-tilt of the court, however, LGBT advocates may not be happy with the court's decision.
With the current disposition of political forces in Washington, it appears probable that the Equality Act's future will be decided by which party succeeds at the ballot box in 2020 - and beyond.
Related Topics
US politics
Taylor Swift
More on this story
Taylor Swift takes top prize at MTV VMAs
27 August 2019
A long journey to LGBT freedom
9 August 2019
Top Stories
US backs waiver on vaccine patents to boost supply
Supporters say the move would increase vaccine production but the pharmaceutical industry disagrees.
58 minutes ago
US students guilty of killing Italian policeman
9 hours ago
India says new variant linked to Covid surge
2 hours ago
Safe Sweden faces up to wave of women's killings
Doctor's diary: Families stranded in Pakistan and India
'We are desperate to go travelling again'
How a sulky Russian model became China's slacker icon
India is a Covid disaster - it didn't have to be
Napoleon's incendiary legacy still divides France
'I wake up every day thinking, what's next?'
The newborn calf that 'crashed our wedding'
Mysterious brain disease in Canada baffles doctors
Elsewhere on the BBC
Football phrases
15 sayings from around the world
Most Read
Malian woman gives birth to nine babies1
Mysterious brain disease in Canada baffles doctors2
US students guilty of killing Italian policeman3
India says new variant linked to Covid surge4
How a sulky Russian model became China's slacker icon5
US backs waiver on vaccine patents to boost supply6
US vows to respond to 'irresponsible' Russian acts7
Bill and Melinda Gates have 'agreed estate split'8
Safe Sweden faces up to wave of women's killings9
Duterte apologises for taking unapproved China jab10
BBC News Services
On your mobile
On smart speakers
Get news alerts
Contact BBC News
Terms of Use
About the BBC
Privacy Policy
Accessibility Help
Parental Guidance
Contact the BBC
Get Personalised Newsletters
Why you can trust the BBC
Advertise with us
AdChoices / Do Not Sell My Info
© 2021 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read about our approach to external linking.
BBC HomepageSkip to contentAccessibility HelpSign inHomeNewsSportReelWorklifeTravelFutureCultureMenuSearchHomeNewsSportReelWorklifeTravelFutureCultureMusicTVWeatherSounds
MenuHomeCoronavirusVideoWorldUS & CanadaUKBusinessTechScienceStoriesEntertainment & ArtsMoreHealthIn PicturesReality CheckWorld News TVNewsbeatLong ReadsUS & Canada